Jay Emmanuel Thomas gave Livingston an equaliser out of nowhere as Celtic’s defence frailties were exposed once again. Ryan Christie lost a 50/50 before a cross in front of the face of goal allowed the unmarked JET to tap the ball in.

Shane Duffy slid across the turf in anticipation of the earlier shot but by doing so he allowed Emmanuel Thomas a tap-in at the back post.

Celtic went ahead through Nir Bitton after Moi Elyounoussi restored parity as Celtic were forced to come from 1-0 down. The first Livi goal also came from some poor Celtic defending.