Ciaron Brown opened the scoring for Livingston versus Celtic at The Tony Macaroni Stadium after some shocking defending from Neil Lennon’s side allowed the defender a free header.

Shane Duffy gave away a needless foul to allow Livi the chance to float it into the box and they duly exposed Celtic’s defensive frailties.

Celtic have a lot of work to do if they are to get a win against a very tough opponent. Although questions need to be asked as to what Celtic do at training if the level of defending remains like this at set pieces?