Celtic’s speed in acting against Green Brigade took the breath away

From the club’s side, the rationale may be less political than practical. Celtic is not just a football club but a publicly listed company operating under strict safety licensing and insurance frameworks. The Rail Seating Section exists only because the club can demonstrate control and compliance.

Any suggestion of disorder, particularly involving police officers, threatens that status. Failure to act decisively could invite scrutiny from the authorities, compromise insurance cover, or even endanger the safe-standing licence itself.

In that light, the board’s swiftness looks like self-preservation. Yet what the board sees as diligence, many supporters interpret as authoritarianism. The process feels opaque, the punishment collective, and the tone corporate, all the things many Celtic supporters have grown to resent.

The truth is this latest clash doesn’t exist in isolation. It’s part of a larger collapse of trust between the boardroom and the stands.

For years, Celtic’s leadership has spoken of “engagement” while rarely practising it. Fans are asked to renew and behave, but seldom consulted. Decisions, on policing, ticketing, or protest, seem made behind closed doors and announced as fait accompli. When challenged, the club’s instinct is defensive, its communication formal and cold.

Continues on the next page…