Martin O’Neill criticises use of VAR after Celtic Park defeat

Martin O’Neill criticised the use of VAR following Celtic’s costly 2-1 defeat by Hibs, arguing that the technology had influence on key moments in the game…

Martin O'Neill.
22.02.2026 Celtic v Hibernian, Scottish Premiership. Martin O’Neill. Photo Kenny Ramsay IMAGO

With the score level at 1-1 with 20 minutes remaining, Celtic were reduced to 10 men when Auston Trusty was sent off after an incident in the penalty area involving Hibs midfielder Jamie McGrath.

O’Neill revealed that referee Matthew MacDermid informed him post-match that he had initially planned only to caution the players before being advised by VAR official Grant Irvine to review the incident.

Following the pitchside check, MacDermid upgraded the punishment, ruling Trusty guilty of violent conduct.

Matthew MacDermid
22.02.2026 Celtic v Hibernian, Scottish Premiership. Matthew MacDermid Photo Kenny Ramsay IMAGO

Celtic’s frustration grew moments immediately after Trusty’s red when Liam Scales fell in the box during a corner after a clear pull on his shirt by Hibs defender Jack Iredale.

Reflecting on Trusty’s dismissal, O’Neill said  at his post match media conference: “Well, I’ve just had a word with the referee. He said he was just going to have a word with the two players, first of all. Then I think VAR intervened and said it was violent conduct.”

When questioned on the Scales incident, O’Neill said: “The referee, I think his words were, he didn’t hold onto him long enough, but it seems a wee bit strange.”

“You’re grabbing someone’s shirt as he’s making a move to get the ball and holding onto his shirt. Some years ago it was a penalty. But VAR, they’ve passed that one on, so there we go.”

O’Neill revealed he spoke to Trusty after the game, saying: “I’ve spoken to him. At the end of it all, you can’t do this. If that’s the rules now, it doesn’t matter if someone is holding onto you, in an attempt to breakaway, you can’t thrust down in the manner in which he did to get away. So I’ve been told it’s violent conduct.”

“The sending off has a big effect. We had the momentum at that stage. We had some chances second half and if you don’t put them away there’s a possibility at the other end.”

Conor Spence

Celtic in the Thirties
Celtic in the Thirties by Matt Corr. Click on image to order

Introducing The Celtic Star App and our new ad-free Premium Service...

Go ad-free on The Celtic Star, get a FREE trial period to try it out. Also download our new App – available for both Apple and Android – and get the best Celtic content on your phone without fighting through pop-up ads and being forced to watch videos.

Our new PREMIUM service comes with a free seven-day trial so you can look before you book. If you are happy to continue the price will be just 99p per month or £9.99 for the year. For that you get an AD-FREE SITE plus access to our premium content, and you’ll also help us make The Celtic Star even better and less reliant on advertising revenues, allowing us to be more focused on publishing the best Celtic features on the internet.

Click HERE to access your FREE trial. We think you’ll like it! We’re Obsessed with Celtic and we think you are too! Join us hand in hand...

About Author

A current fourth year student studying History and Journalism, Media and Communications at the University of Strathclyde and now writing regularly about the Hoops for The Celtic Star.

Welcome to our Live Comments section, where new comments will appear automatically

2 Comments

  1. VAR IS NOT THE PROBLEM ITS THE IDIOTS WHO ARE USEING IT, THEY INVENT RULES TO SUIT THEMSELFS, AND THAT CLOWN OF A REF McDERMOT SHOULD GO BACK TO SCHOOL FOOTBALL , IS WULLIE COLUM HIS MENtor ?