Aberdeen’s bitter songbook then bitter taste of defeat after Celtic’s victory

Aberdeen supporters are taking to losing to Celtic just like their rival supporters from Ibrox. They were even using their bitter songbook on Wednesday night…

Alistair Johnston
4th December 2024; Pittodrie Stadium, Aberdeen, Scottish Premiership l, Aberdeen versus Celtic; Sivert Heltne Nilsen of Aberdeen fouls Alistair Johnston of Celtic. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

Aberdeen have been a breath of fresh air this campaign. They’ve started the season in fine form while playing some good football as they currently sit second in the table.

Bitter Together

Although I’ll not extend the courtesy to their supporters who have quite frankly rather bad losers, a bit like the supporters of the side who currently sit in third place and are challenging the Dons for the runners up spot in the Scottish Premiership.

The Aberdeen songbook was every bit as bitter as their Ibrox and Tynecastle counterparts on Wednesday night ad it makes Celtic winning at their middens all the more enjoyable.

And after our narrow win at Pittodrie on Wednesday night, the Aberdeen fans have done nothing but whine about certain selected ‘incidents’ on the night.

Callum McGregor is fouled
Callum McGregor is fouled. 4th December 2024; Pittodrie, Aberdeen, ; Scottish Premiership Football, Aberdeen versus Celtic. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

Celtic burst Aberdeen’s bubble at Hampden 

I wouldn’t say we fully deserved to win, but we certainly didn’t deserve to lose, and a draw would have been an acceptable result on the night as far as Celtic are concerned. Given their recent form dip since we happened them 6-0 at Hampden, Aberdeen really had to win on Wednesday night to keep their title fantasy alive.

How Celtic’s class won the game as Reo Hatate took the one clear cut chance that fell his way, and that would prove to be the difference on the night. Aberdeen had one big chance near the end and as Neil Lennon said on Sky Sports he really should have scored.

Reo Hatate is brought down
Reo Hatate is brought down. 4th December 2024; Pittodrie, Scottish Premiership, Aberdeen versus Celtic. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

Stats don’t lie

If there was going to be a winner then that would have been Celtic and not Aberdeen. Look at the stats:

Possession – Aberdeen 26% Celtic 74%. Shots – Aberdeen 8 Celtic 15. On Target 4 each. Corners Aberdeen 2 Celtic 10. 

So what exactly are the Aberdeen fans moaning about? No decision from the officials affected the outcome of the game in any way on the night as far as I can recall.

Kyogo and Ross Doohan collide
Kyogo and Ross Doohan collide. 4th December 2024; Pittodrie, Aberdeen, ; Scottish Premiership Football, Aberdeen versus Celtic. Photo Vagelis Georgariou
  • Kyogo didn’t intend to harm the goalkeeper, it was a fair and honest  challenge from both players and the ball was there to be won.
  • Cameron Carter Vickers didn’t deserve a red card for his well time tackle on a Dons player in the second half.
Cameron Carter-Vickers
4th December 2024; Pittodrie, Aberdeen, ; Scottish Premiership Football, Aberdeen versus Celtic; Cameron Carter-Vickers of Celtic on the ball. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

Graeme Shinnie should have had a second yellow

These two ‘incidents’ received no punishment, because there was no offence to pursue. End of story. The Dons supporters are embarrassing themselves like their rival supporters from Ibrox by whining about such claims.

Incidentally the one decision that the on field referee got wrong on the night was his bizarre decision not to hand Graeme Shinnie a second caution in the final minute of the game.

Don Robertson
4th December 2024; Pittodrie, Scottish Premiership, Aberdeen versus Celtic; Referee Don Robertson speaks to Graeme Shinnie of Aberdeen. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

Funny they don’t want to talk about that…

Another was that Duk chap hitting the ground repeatedly all night, getting young Valle booked for nothing at all and even diving to try to con a penalty out of Don Robertson – why no card for that?

Alex Valle booked by Don Robertson
4th December 2024; Pittodrie; Scottish Premiership , Aberdeen versus Celtic; Alex Valle of Celtic is yellow carded by referee Don Robertson. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

Just an Ordinary Bhoy

Celtic in the Thirties by Matt Corr
Celtic in the Thirties by Matt Corr, Volumes One & Two, Published by Celtic Star Books

CELTIC IN THE THIRTIES, VOLUMES ONE & TWO BY MATT CORR – OUT NOW! Order your signed copies below…

Click to order from Celtic Star Books

Order your signed copies from Celtic Star Books
Celtic in the Thirties by Celtic Historian Matt Corr is published in two volumes by Celtic Star Books. OUT NOW!

About Author

An ordinary everyday Celtic supporters hailing and still residing in Govan in the shadows of the enemy. I’m a season ticket holder. I Witnessed my first Celtic game in 1988 and have attended when I can ever since. Growing up in the 90s I witnessed Celtic at their lowest, and now appreciate the historic success we enjoy today. I enjoy writing about this wonderful football club and hopefully will continue to do so. I’ve always been a keen writer and initially started this a hobby. My ambition is to one day become as good an author as my fellow Celtic Star colleagues.

7 Comments

  1. We did deserve to win.
    Their fans vile songbook been audible for a few years now.
    A Millwall of a football club.

  2. Celtic fans have no right to comment on the songbook or behaviour of other teams fans given the IRA songbook and the constant f the huns. what abut the remembrance day disruption, no respect for other Celtic fans who wanted to observe it!! we all need to move away from this and start supporting the players on the pitch.

    • Well said. Couldn’t agree more. What have the IRA ever done for Celtic Football Club, why even bring the Pope into our songbook. We are a football club, not a political or religious organisation.

    • Can’t believe about so called fan, going on about F the Huns,they may chant if you hate the rangers cap your hands
      The protest on remembrance day was because of Atrocities commited by British Army I Ireland and Bloody Sunday.So if your not happy go elsewhere

  3. As I have said previously, in my humble opinion, Remembrance Day is and should be appropriate and a matter of choice. Cenotaphs are there for remembrance and those who want to can observe this in silence. Nobody is stopping them. It should not happen at public events where people have no choice and are uncomfortable with it being a public show. The whole poppy thing and remembrance has become weaponised and that is really quite disrespectful in itself. Hypocrisy is once again at the heart of this, where opinions and behaviours are being forced on others. Do it at the appropriate location and don’t subject others to it to make it a show.

    “All that glitters is not gold”.

    • Didn’t deserve to win?

      I’ve no idea what game you were watching, this Celtic team’s persistence in playing football despite the horrendous conditions and a referee who has a history of allowing competitors to plough through challenges at will is admirable…..

      Celtic FC were more worthy winners….

      HH