Bankier was Correct – Read the Response we got from Scottish Government

Ian Bankier was correct today, Celtic were treated differently by the Scottish Government and SFA. The Celtic Star contacted the Scottish Government and their response, published below, is well worth reading….

Ian Bankier might not be the most popular person at Celtic but the club chairman was bang on today in what he said about the treatment dished out our club last season by the Scottish Government.

Indeed the only criticism worth making on this subject that was discussed at the Celtic AGM today is what Bankier did NOT say and that would have been to compare and contrast the way that the very same Government treated theRangers totally differently when they have their own Covid issues to deal with later in that season.

The Celtic Star spent a great deal of time and effort trying to get some clarity from the Scottish Government on this matter and indeed we did eventually get a formal response, which was entirely irrelevant and failed to answer any of the points we had raised with them. You can read that below.

Responding to a shareholder’s question on Celtic being treated differently for Covid related matters by both the Scottish FA and the Scottish Government last season, Bankier said:

“Oh I’m in no doubt that we had the worst rub of the green that you could possibly imagine. You couldn’t have written it down on a piece of paper the number of things that went wrong.

“I think we were astonishingly treated by the Scottish Government. We were the only employer in Scotland to be given sanctions for an employee breaching rules.

“That was the start of the downward slide, or the loss of momentum early last season, where we and Aberdeen were banned from playing for two games. It stopped the momentum.

“We also had an undue course of luck in terms of injuries through international breaks. We had James Forrest out, we had a lot of things go wrong. It was almost ‘what’s going to go wrong next?’

“It was terrible, absolutely terrible, but I’m not shying away from the fact that there were other aspects of the season where we just might have done a bit better, but we didn’t do. But yeah, I’m absolutely a supporter on that.”

Bankier was asked what he had done about this unfair treatment at the time. He replied: “Well, if the First Minister of Scotland stands up and says I want a red card or a yellow card to be shown to Celtic Football Club, what is it you do? Do you take them on?

“We made our views really clear to the Scottish FA, which is our conduit for communication.

“If you go toe-to-toe with an organisation with the scale, breadth and power of a government, you will almost certainly make things a lot worse, therefore we chose not to do that.

“We had to get back to playing our games.”

This from The Celtic Star on 26 March 2021…

Celtic’s Yellow Card then the “We Commend Rangers” Statement – Contacting Nicola Sturgeon and her Government’s reply

Trying to get an answer from the Scottish Government regarding their different treatment towards both Celtic and Aberdeen regarding players’ Covid restriction breach of protocols throughout this season has not been easy. That didn’t stop The Celtic Star trying…

A quick re-cap. Various Aberdeen players were photographed out in city centre bars after their opening day defeat to theRangers at Pittodrie. Meanwhile shortly after that Celtic’s Boli Bolingoli headed over to Spain for a sleep-over after Celtic opening day victory over Hamilton. He arrived back, was on the bench for the game at Kilmarnock and came on in the closing stages.

Photo: Jeff Holmes

Nicola Sturgeon’s anger was apparent and both Celtic and Aberdeen were told by the First Minister that they would not be playing for their next two games – something that put Celtic on the back foot in the league from pretty much the early stages – and Scottish football was also issued with a yellow card by Nicola Sturgeon, who pointed out she as using language that football would understand and that we all know what comes after a yellow.

When at the end of last year two players from theRangers Jordan Jones and George Edmundson were issued with Fixed Penalty Notices from Police Scotland for being caught breaching the lockdown rules by attending a house party – believed to be a birthday party for a teammate who appeared not to be there – a Scottish Government spokesperson released a statement COMMENDING theRangers for taking swift action agains their two Covidiots.

There was no mention of this latest breach by Scottish Premiership players – unlike on the earlier occasions involving Aberdeen and Celtic players and there was therefore no further threats of yellow or red cards being issued.

Then there was the second breach from theRangers squad, this time involving FIVE players – Nathan Patterson, Bongani Zungu, Calvin Bassey, Dapo Mebude and Brian Kinnear – and the SFA Tribunal into their breaches of the Covid rules was heard yesterday, with a decision expected on Monday. Remarkably these players have been allowed to continue to play – Patterson has actually played in Europa League matches and came on as a substitute at Celtic Park on Sunday.

Photo by Stuart Wallace

I contacted both my MP and MSP about this with the former, Alyn Smith MP, directing the matter to Bruce Crawford (SNP) MSP for Stirling constituency. Bruce, who is a football man and is a passionate Dunfermline Athletic supporter, understood the point I was making regarding the inconsistencies and promised to raise the matter with the relevant  Minister. Nothing happened though so after another round of chasing up he agreed to write directly to Nicola Sturgeon on my behalf.

Now over the past few weeks I recognise that Nicola Sturgeon has had plenty of more pressing matters to deal with and it has to be noted that she handled these issues that threatened her position as First Minister very well indeed. She has been an outstanding First Minister, has handled the Covid crisis as well as anyone could expect and the SNP will retain the support of many of those reading this – including myself.

That however does not mean that the way the football breaches this season were handled can be regarded as fair, even handed or reasonable. And her party is hardly likely to find much favour with the Unionist leaning supporters of theRangers. But as First Minister party political matters have to be secondary during a time of national crisis. But fairness is essential otherwise people are left disappointed, frustrated and even angry.

Here is the letter that Bruce Crawford MSP sent to First Minister Nicola Sturgeon on my behalf and the reply he received from the Scottish Government yesterday. Make of it what you will. The matter incidentally will be revisited after the Election which presumably she will win…

Ms Nicola Sturgeon MSP
First Minister
Scottish Government
St. Andrews House
Regent Road
Edinburgh
EH1 3DG

22 February 2021

Dear First Minister,

Rangers Football Club

I am writing to you on behalf of a constituent who recently contacted me in relation to the above.

My constituent tells me that five players employed by Rangers Football Club were recently discovered by Police Scotland attending a social gathering in violation of the Scottish Government’s public health regulations.

My constituent’s view is that there is an inconsistency in the approach being taken regarding this incident, and the one that was taken following breaches by players of Celtic and Aberdeen in August of last year.

My constituent therefore asks why Celtic’s game was postponed and the club issued with a yellow card for their breach of the coronavirus (COVID-19) guidelines, while Rangers appear to have committed two such breaches and have not had similar action taken against them, but rather had a statement from the Scottish Government commending their actions after the first breach.

Given the above, I would be grateful for your consideration of my constituent’s views and for any comment you are able to provide in relation to the points that he has raised.

I thank you for your attention to this matter and I look forward to your response. Kind regards,

Bruce Crawford (SNP)
MSP for Stirling constituency

THE RESPONSE arrived yesterday and came from Scottish Government DIRECTORATE FOR SAFER COMMUNITIES, DSF: Police Division…

25 March 2021

Dear Bruce Crawford MSP,

Thank you for your email of 22 February to the First Minister for Scotland Nicola Sturgeon MSP, regarding football players reportedly breaching the Coronavirus Regulations. As we are now in a pre-election period, I am responding on her behalf.

Enforcement of the Regulations is a matter for the Chief Constable of Police Scotland. The Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Act 2012 stipulates that the Chief Constable is responsible for the policing of
Scotland, and is accountable to the Scottish Police Authority for this, rather than to Scottish Ministers directly. These arrangements are in place to ensure public confidence that the police act independently, free from unwarranted Ministerial interference. Therefore, the Scottish Government cannot comment on the police handling of the case that you mention or the action taken by police officers in responding to this specific incident.

Police Scotland have been clear that they will continue to operate under the principle of policing by consent and follow the 4Es approach whereby they will Engage, Explain, Encourage and only then, if faced with wilful and blatant non-compliance, Enforce the coronavirus regulations – by for example issuing a Fixed Penalty Notice -as a last resort to protect public health.

From the outset of the pandemic, the Scottish Government has worked in partnership with the football authorities and clubs to ensure that the appropriate public health measures are in place. The Scottish Football Association is responsible for breach investigations, and the associated relevant sanctions.

The Scottish Government has highlighted on a number of occasions the obligations and restrictions on clubs.

It is vital that everyone, both in professional sport and across the wider population, understands the need to strictly follow all protocols and guidance to stop the spread of the virus and keep the country safe.

I hope your constituent finds this response helpful.

Yours sincerely

Ryan Paterson
POLICE : Powers and Workforce Unit

About Author

The Celtic Star founder and editor, who has edited numerous Celtic books over the past decade or so including several from Lisbon Lions, Willie Wallace, Tommy Gemmell and Jim Craig. Earliest Celtic memories include a win over East Fife at Celtic Park and the 4-1 League Cup loss to Partick Thistle as a 6 year old. Best game? Easy 4-2, 1979 when Ten Men Won the League. Email editor@thecelticstar.co.uk

2 Comments

  1. The first breach was at murray park before the season started it was put down to a misunderstanding ?. The ryan christie fiasco. Scotland under 19 game getting abandoned at half time due to a positive case. Madden and the two linesman farce which got little publicity. The two months delay to punish newco players ?. Rules were made up on the spot where no such rules existed and they still do not exist to this day.