Sandman’s Definitive Ratings – Celtic v Gerogeorwell

Showing 2 of 4

CALMAC – 6.5/10 – Still not getting control of the game and still not getting the support required to exact that. But he’ll dig, dig, dig – because he’s the Celtic skipper and example is his to set. And he’ll feel good getting that over the line today because he was on his heels for much of it, having to circle back as their counter-press had very mobile brawn blocking his guile. I’ll say it again – get the right bodyguard in beside Calmac and we dominate.

HIGHLAND TOFFEE – 5.5/10 – Luke, a big chance, but Luke, a bit of a flop. This was made for his swashbuckling style but, as previously, the moment expectation hits, his form lets him down and the numerous impacts he’s made off the bench don’t get replicated when the jersey’s his to claim. Damn.

HAKUNA HATATE – 6/10 – Well, Reo looked energised and busy for a frantic first-half display. His play was alert and inventive – a bit of the old Reo we love. Something happened at the interval, though – maybe told to cut short an episode of Battle Of The Planets to get back out there? – but we missed his influence as he faded out of it.

Daizen Maeda

Daizen Maeda of Celtic scores a late goal during the Scottish Premiership match between Celtic FC and Motherwell FC at Celtic Park, on 5th October 2025. Photo Mark Runnacles IMAGO/Shutterstock

LORD KATSUMOTO – 7/10 – Ha! Finally, Daizen-down-the-middle pays off once more! The much-maligned wantaway hero adds to his Celtic legend with a crucial winner which will be fondly remembered as a spectacular double-cousins-sickener. Only Daizen, with the insight of a Roshi, would diving-heider a ball 4 millimetres off the turf, but that he did and lifted the day to ecstasy. Around his moment he’d blown hot and cold but never petulant; always buzzing them. And even to the bitter end he was conceding tactical free-kicks, standing over them, and eyeballing the MIB as he took a card. Arigato, Sensei.

TUTANKHAMUN – 5.5/10 – Flattered to deceive, ultimately, but did look like there was more to come until he was benched and we lost that trickery which is more likely to open tired defences than get the better of early, energetic legs. Bit baffling, but not the only thing.

Kelechi Iheanacho of Celtic scores

Kelechi Iheanacho of Celtic scores a penalty during the Scottish Premiership match between Celtic FC and Motherwell FC at Celtic Park, on 5th October 2025 Photo by Mark Runnacles IMAGO /Shutterstock

ITCHYCOO PARK – 6.5/10 – The striker we need. Also, the striker we might need to score winners late in games but doesn’t yet see them out…But you can see the class in his natural target-man play. Movement and linkage is what’s required; if he had pace he’d be devastating. Slotted in that penalty with a wily striker’s instinctive change of placement, putting the keeper in the North Curve. Just get him fit and keep him engaged, he’ll score almost as much as Jamesy on a Shmagaluf weekender.

Continues on the next page…
Showing 2 of 4

About Author

The Celtic Star founder and editor David Faulds has edited numerous Celtic books over the past decade or so including several from Lisbon Lions, Willie Wallace, Tommy Gemmell and Jim Craig. Earliest Celtic memories include a win over East Fife at Celtic Park and the 4-1 League Cup loss to Partick Thistle as a 6 year old. Best game? Easy 4-2, 1979 when Ten Men Won the League. Email [email protected]

Welcome to our Live Comments section, where new comments will appear automatically

5 Comments

  1. Brendan’s big flaw this season to date is keeping faith with Calmac.
    You believe he needs a minder to flourish.
    He didn’t need a minder in previous seasons.
    Unfortunately Calmac is in decline and shouldn’t be an automatic pick..
    His problem is physical not mental.
    The break should see a reset.
    Treble on.
    Hail Hail.

    • I do believe he needs a ‘minder’ Jhn, precisely for the reason you stipulate – physical workload.

      He’s lost a yard of pace BUT not the cognitive genius of a natural born footballer.

      So what I’m saying is get someone in there closer to him than ever before to give him the time he can’t buy himself. He’ll still pull the strings and play the pases as well as ever if we facillitate that.

      • When does BR decide that Calmac cannot perform for 90 mins?
        A great player in decline different from Daizen having a loss of form.
        He knew when he retired fom Scotland duties that the legs weren’t there.
        I hope I’m wrong.
        Keep scribbling.👏👏👏
        Hail Hail.

  2. 39
    27 28 27 27
    28 32 28
    28 29 23

    “You’re only 29
    Got a lot to learn
    But when your business dies
    You will not return”

    What Celtic needs is youthful spunk and risk-takers playing for their future not the final salary schemers and mortugees preferred by consecutive Celtic managers. Ben Summers(21) & Osmand(20) trained with 1st team on Friday but were not even on the bench of average age=25 years old. Starting eleven 29 years old average.

    Jock Stein will be turning in his grave. O’Neill the last manager who reared several Celtic-class 1st team players through the ranks more than 20 years ago – i.e. Maloney, Marshall, Kennedy and McGeady.