Brendan Rodgers is right to question VAR. but let’s not let it deflect from the fact we were so poor in the first half and Hibs probably deserved the victory…
Brendan Rodgers like most Celtic supporters was enraged by the decision to disallow what would’ve been a late ‘equaliser’ after Alistair Johnson’s cross was said to have happened after the ball was out of play before Daizen Maeda struck the ball into the Hibs net.
Alan Muir needs to explain his decision
The Celtic manager was understandably upset and gave his opinion on the matter in his post match interviews, the one with BBC Scotland is shown below. Brendan spoke for the rest of us when he questioned the overruling of the decision of the on field officials by VAR Alan Muir and wants to hear a full explanation on the matter.
“We don’t have the cameras to say that it’s factually out. If you don’t, you’re having a guess”
Brendan Rodgers on Celtic’s disallowed goal against Hibs ⤵️#BBCFootball pic.twitter.com/RvnEKRDfhX
— BBC Sport Scotland (@BBCSportScot) February 22, 2025
If they did Indeed go with the images we have all now seen, then we have every right to demand answers as it was inconclusive, therefore any decision would have been a matter of mere guesswork and certainly not based on anything factual. In the absence of any such evidence then Muir should have told the referee Steven McLean to go with his on-field decision.
This is the best angle I’ve seen. The picture of the yellow ball in the second tweet shows what is considered to be in-play – it only needs to be touching the line. To have a goal overturned by VAR on this basis is incredible. pic.twitter.com/DH0GFlw841
— David 🍀 (@thedavidcurrie) February 23, 2025
The better footage from the Hibs Vlogger that emerged today only serves to make matters worse for Muir whose position must be close to becoming untenable. Over the you Willie Collum.
My point was you can't conclusively say the ball was out without a birdseye view.
Explained with video & picture examples in below thread, camera from 18 yard line will make it look out, but it might not be.
Without conclusive evidence, VAR cannot change the on field decision https://t.co/GYs1PW4MmX pic.twitter.com/ul9qYFwvyi
— Scotland’s Coefficient (@scotlandscoeff1) February 23, 2025
Hibs deserved the three points
All that said however, we shouldn’t let it deflect from the fact that Celtic were poor on the day and Hibs were in my opinion the morning after the day before, deserving of the three points.
We can demand answers from the powers that be at the fraternity, but that doesn’t mean we have to use it as a deflection from our own on field failures at Easter Road. We can leave those sort of shenanigans to other clubs, the ones that desperately need to distract themselves and everyone else from their own failures.
READ THIS…Sandman’s Definitive Ratings – Renton’s Rovers v Celtic
Have a look at this…
“There’s ambiguity. It’s an optical illusion!” 👁️@GNev2 explains the different angles when a ball is sitting on the touchline 🎥🤨 pic.twitter.com/JgIo1xSbWW
— Sky Sports Premier League (@SkySportsPL) November 6, 2023
And remember this from earlier in the season…
Alan Muir on VAR, I believe?
— Lint (@Zeshankenzo) February 23, 2025
Just an Ordinary Bhoy
Sign up and receive a free Henrik Larsson book…
Hibs
Hibs “probably” deserved a victory so no other teams fighting
for a top six place affected then
2
;
hibs probably deserved a draw if the actual rules of the game had been followed
This is an interesting header, though slightly overstated.
I would 100% agree that Hibbs did NOT deserve to lose! The correct result would have been a 2-2 draw. The first half was all Hibs. No question about it.
They were well worth their two goals.
But in the second half they rarely got over the halfway line and most of the time had all eleven men back behind the ball, and this isn’t a criticism, it’s just a fact. It was a team fighting to stay in the lead.
But neither fact alters the bad decision by VAR especially when it was so obviously inconclusive! The VERY PURPOSE of VAR is to prove and remove all doubts!
This decision was designed to make sure Celtic lost yesterday to help the SFA establishment club, playing later in the day at home to St. Mirren. But THAT exploded in the faces of Willie Collum’s corrupt plans!
But regardless, back to the beginning here, Hibs did not deserve to lose, but neither did Celtic!
I am pretty sure the SFA have shown their hand at the additional hurdles we have to jump over to win the treble this season!